Thursday, December 6, 2012

Albrecht's Master Law: Collective Stupidity

Albrecht's Master Law, which has never been refuted, says that "Intelligent people, when assembled into an organization, will tend toward collective stupidity."

In the early morning hours of September 30, 1999, NASA's Mars Climate Orbiter spacecraft, a 125 million dollar marvel of American technology and engineering, whizzed toward the red planet at 17,000 miles per hour, exactly as planned. The crew of technical wizards at CalTech's Jet Propulsion Lab, and other points around the world, waited tensely for the signals that would tell them it had successfully entered a stable orbit. They waited. And waited.

Suddenly, the signal from its on-board transmitter faded and died, and the craft was never heard from again. Stunned and horrified, the experts worked feverishly around the clock to figure out what had gone wrong, and tried to re-establish contact with the craft.

After days of careful testing and analysis, they reluctantly concluded that the ship had probably approached Mars at an altitude of less than 60 kilometers rather than the 150 kilometers as planned. This was far too close and the spacecraft likely burned to a cinder due to friction with the atmosphere.

JPL's management and the top management of NASA went into crisis mode. A careful investigation revealed that the engineers who wrote the navigation software for the mission had been working in separate groups, and had apparently not approached the mission as a whole.

Incredibly, one group had been programming its calculations using metric units — kilometers and kilograms — while the other had been using American-style English units — miles and pounds. Since a kilometer is about six-tenths of a mile, and a kilogram is about 2.2 pounds, well...

The director of the Mission Failure Investigation Board said: "The ... board has identified other significant factors that allowed this error to be born, and then let it linger and propagate to the point where it resulted in a major error in our understanding of the spacecraft's path as it approached Mars." This was code language for a series of organizational blunders that doomed the orbiter to oblivion.

How could some of the most intelligent human beings on the planet — as they indeed were — create such a stunningly unintelligent collective result? Before we condemn the parties involved and impugn their competence, let's remember that events like the orbiter loss occur every day in business organizations, all over the world. Few of them are spectacular enough to make the world news shows, and the majority probably don't cost a hundred million dollars or more, but collective stupidity — let's be blunt about it — goes on all around us in the business world.

At a practical level, any person who's ever worked in an organization for even a modest period of time has witnessed, probably on a daily basis, its potential for wasting human intelligence and talent, thwarting the best intentions of well-motivated people, and even pitting intelligent people against one another in ways never intended by any of the parties involved. It's time we stopped overlooking, denying, rationalizing, and avoiding dealing with organizational dysfunction. We need to face it, look it squarely in the eye, understand it, and come to terms with its causes.